XUS vs CSPX: Which S&P 500 ETF Should Singapore Investors Buy?

—

I’ve been buying CSPX since August 2024. It’s an Ireland-domiciled ETF that tracks the S&P 500, giving me exposure to some of the largest companies in the US.

Buying CSPX means investing in a US-dollar trading line on the London Stock Exchange. Then XUS arrived on the Singapore Exchange (SGX) in October 2026.

XUS tracks the same S&P 500 Index, charges a lower annual fee, and can be bought directly in Singapore dollars. Is XUS a better choice than CSPX for Singapore investors, especially those investing a fixed amount every month? Let’s compare the fees, performance, taxes and trading costs.

XUS vs CSPX: What’s the Difference?

Both ETFs invest in large US companies such as Apple, Microsoft, NVIDIA and Amazon. Both are domiciled in Ireland and automatically reinvest dividends. Their main differences are fees, trading currencies and trading history.

FeatureXUSCSPX
Fund providerXtrackers (DWS)iShares (BlackRock)
Stock exchangeSGXLondon Stock Exchange
Trading currencySGDUSD
Fund domicileIrelandIreland
Index trackedS&P 500S&P 500
Annual expense ratio0.03%0.07%
Dividend treatmentAccumulatingAccumulating
ReplicationPhysicalPhysical
Share class launchJune 2022May 2010
SGX listingOctober 2026Not applicable
ISINIE000Z9SJA06IE00B5BMR087
Sources: DWS, iShares and SGX. Information reviewed in November 2026.

XUS looks attractive at first glance: lower fees and SGD trading for exposure to the same US stock market. But the cheapest ETF on paper isn’t necessarily the cheapest one to buy.

XUS Has Lower Fees, but How Much Do You Actually Save?

XUS charges 0.03% a year compared with 0.07% for CSPX. Here’s what that 0.04-percentage-point difference means in dollars.

Investment amount (USD)XUS annual feeCSPX annual feeAnnual savings
$10,000$3$7$4
$50,000$15$35$20
$100,000$30$70$40
$500,000$150$350$200
Illustration assumes the investment value stays unchanged. Fees are reflected within fund performance, not billed separately.

Even with $100,000 invested, the fee difference is only $40 a year. Lower fees matter over time, but brokerage commissions and currency conversion costs can outweigh those savings for someone buying small amounts regularly.

For example, if I invested $1,000 every month and paid an extra $2 for each trade, that’s $24 in extra trading costs over a year. Compare that with $4 of annual fee savings on a $10,000 holding. These are illustrative figures, but they explain why I wouldn’t choose based on the expense ratio alone.

Buying XUS in SGD: Is That Really an Advantage?

One of XUS’s biggest selling points is that it trades in SGD. With XUS, I can use Singapore dollars through a broker offering SGX trading. With CSPX, I generally need to convert into USD to buy its London-listed trading line.

Buying an ETF in SGD doesn’t remove currency risk. Both funds own US companies, whose values are exposed to the US dollar. If USD weakens against SGD, that can reduce the SGD value of either investment, even when the US stock market performs well. The trading currency changes how I pay, not what I own.

The price of one unit also matters to smaller investors. On 23 October 2026, XUS closed at about S$19 per unit while CSPX was around US$826 per share. XUS is therefore easier to buy in smaller amounts when a broker does not support fractional ETF purchases.

XUS is also eligible for Singapore’s Supplementary Retirement Scheme (SRS), making it an option for investors using SRS funds.

XUS vs CSPX: What About Dividend Withholding Tax?

For Singapore-based investors, US dividend withholding tax matters. US-domiciled ETFs generally have 30% deducted from ordinary dividends paid to Singapore-resident non-US investors. Ireland-domiciled funds that own US shares generally benefit from a 15% withholding rate at the fund level under the US–Ireland tax treaty.

Because both XUS and CSPX are Irish-domiciled, they receive broadly the same treatment. Here’s a simplified illustration using $10,000 invested and an assumed 1% dividend yield.

Dividend calculationUS-domiciled ETFXUS / CSPX
Gross dividends$100$100
US withholding rate30%15%
Withholding tax$30$15
Dividends remaining$70$85
Illustration of ordinary US dividends only; actual fund taxation and returns vary.

Neither XUS nor CSPX pays that amount to investors as cash. They’re accumulating ETFs, so the income left after fund-level taxes stays in the fund. The benefit appears in the fund’s value rather than a dividend payment in your brokerage account.

What About US Estate Tax?

Non-US individuals with more than $60,000 of US-situated assets at death may face US estate tax filing requirements. Shares in Irish-domiciled corporate ETFs are generally not treated like directly owning US-situated shares. Since XUS and CSPX are both Irish-domiciled, neither has a clear advantage on this point.

For more background, see my US vs Ireland-domiciled S&P 500 ETF guide. Tax rules depend on individual circumstances, so check professional guidance when needed.

XUS vs CSPX: Which Has Better Performance?

Both ETFs track the same index, so their long-term returns should be close. Differences can come from fees, index tracking, securities lending and other fund-level effects.

Although XUS began SGX trading only in October 2026, its underlying share class has existed since June 2022. Its earlier returns can therefore be compared with CSPX, as long as we don’t mistake those figures for historical SGD trading returns on SGX.

Calendar yearXUS share classCSPX
202325.91%25.9%
202424.69%24.7%
202517.60%17.6%
Sources: DWS and iShares fund data reviewed 23 October 2026. USD-based calendar-year fund returns with dividends reinvested, not the return of the new SGD listing.

The results are almost identical. Despite XUS’s lower fee, those years don’t show a meaningful performance advantage. This is why I look at tracking results, not just the stated expense ratio.

Both funds also face the same basic risk: if the S&P 500 falls sharply, the value of either holding can fall too.

Does CSPX Have Better Liquidity Than XUS?

CSPX has a much longer trading history and substantially larger fund size. CSPX had around $157 billion in assets compared with roughly $4 billion for the Xtrackers fund. The London CSPX trading line also showed more trading activity than XUS’s first few SGX sessions.

But lower exchange trading volume doesn’t automatically mean an ETF is difficult to buy or sell. ETF market makers can help keep prices aligned with the value of the underlying shares. What I’d check before placing an order is the bid-ask spread: the difference between what buyers offer and sellers ask.

Suppose the buying price is $20.00 and the selling price is $20.04. That’s a $0.04 spread, or about 0.20% of the buying price. A spread like that is worth several years of XUS’s 0.03% annual fund fee. It doesn’t mean XUS always has a wider spread than CSPX; spreads change through the day.

I would check live prices and consider a limit order rather than assuming the displayed price is the best available.

Should I Switch From CSPX to XUS?

Since I’ve been buying CSPX since August 2024, this is the part that interests me most. XUS offers lower fees and SGD trading, which are genuine advantages for someone making new investments.

But switching an existing CSPX holding means selling shares and buying XUS. That could involve commissions, currency conversion charges and bid-ask spreads.

For example, on a $50,000 position, the annual expense-ratio saving is about $20. If switching costs $100 overall, it would take roughly five years to recover that cost through fee savings alone, assuming the position value and fee difference stay unchanged.

That doesn’t account for differences in future tracking performance. A lower fee by itself wouldn’t be enough reason for me to sell an existing CSPX holding.

XUS vs CSPX: Which ETF Should You Choose?

Your situationETF worth consideringWhy
Invest small amounts regularly in SGDXUSSmaller unit price and SGD trading
Invest through SRSXUSSGX-listed and SRS-eligible
Already hold CSPXCSPXAvoid unnecessary switching costs
Prefer an established, active listingCSPXLonger trading history
Want the lowest stated annual expense ratioXUS0.03% versus 0.07%
Want Irish-domiciled US dividend tax treatmentEitherBoth are Irish-domiciled

For someone starting an S&P 500 portfolio in Singapore, XUS is an interesting option. Its lower annual fee, SGD trading and smaller unit price make it accessible for regular investing. CSPX remains a sensible option for investors using international brokers who are comfortable buying in USD.

Personally, having invested in CSPX since 2024, I don’t see a compelling reason to switch purely to save 0.04 percentage points in annual fees.

The more important question is whether I want to keep investing in the S&P 500 itself. Listing an ETF on a different exchange doesn’t add geographic diversification: both funds still own US stocks. If you’re considering a broader portfolio, I’ve also compared CSPX, IWDA and VWRA.

XUS gives Singapore investors one more low-cost way to buy the S&P 500. Whether it is actually cheaper for you depends on how much you invest, how often you trade, and which broker you use. Would you choose XUS for SGD convenience, or stick with CSPX?

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes and reflects my personal research and investing experience. It is not financial, investment or tax advice. Fund fees, trading conditions and tax rules can change. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Suz avatar

Suz

I left my tech job at 45 and now build income from dividends, covered call ETFs and selling options. This is where I share what I’m learning.

Leave a Reply

● About Me
Suz avatar

I’m Suz, and this is my journey of learning to live off my investment portfolio without a regular paycheck.

Read my story →