GPIX vs VOO – Is the Extra Income Worth It?

—

VOO is one of the cheapest ways to own the S&P 500. GPIX holds much the same companies but turns part of their upside into a monthly payout. I wanted to see what that trade-off has actually cost since GPIX launched. In this article, we will be doing a comparison of GPIX (Goldman Sachs S&P 500 Premium Income ETF) vs VOO (Vanguard S&P 500 ETF).

The main difference between GPIX vs VOO is, GPIX holds the S&P 500 stocks and sells call options on part of the portfolio to pay a monthly income. VOO, on the other hand, simply tracks the S&P 500 Index, keeps all of the upside and pays a small quarterly dividend.

Read on for a more comprehensive coverage.

Quick Verdict

VOO suits long-term growth: it has delivered the higher total return at a much lower fee (0.03% vs 0.29% net). GPIX suits investors who want regular monthly income from the S&P 500 and accept giving up some upside.

An Overview of GPIX vs VOO

Goldman Sachs S&P 500 Premium Income ETF / (GPIX)Vanguard S&P 500 ETF / (VOO)
Management StyleActive ETFPassive, full replication of the S&P 500
Inception Date24 Oct 20237 Sep 2010
Expense Ratio0.29% net (0.35% gross)0.03%
Number of Holdings488 (12 Oct 2026)506 stocks (30 Jun 2026)
Payout frequencyMonthlyQuarterly
Trailing 12-month payout ÷ 30 Sep price8.16%1.06%
AUM$6.03 B (30 Sep 2026)$978.96 B (ETF share class, 30 Jun 2026)
Sources: Goldman Sachs monthly update, 30 Sep 2026; GPIX prospectus, 30 Apr 2026; Vanguard VOO fact sheet, 30 Jun 2026; stockanalysis GPIX, 12 Oct 2026; Yahoo Finance GPIX, Yahoo Finance VOO, 30 Sep 2026

GPIX holds the S&P 500 stocks and sells call options on 25% to 75% of the portfolio. The option premiums fund a monthly payout, which Goldman Sachs reports at an annualised 8.50% for each of the last 12 months.

VOO simply tracks the S&P 500. Vanguard describes it as using “a passively managed, full-replication strategy”, and it keeps all of the index’s upside.

GPIX has an expense ratio of 0.29% net compared to VOO’s 0.03%. This means that for every $10,000 you invest, you are paying $29 and $3 respectively each year in management expenses. GPIX’s 0.29% depends on a fee waiver that runs “through at least April 30, 2027”; its gross fee is 0.35%.

On a like-for-like basis (the last 12 months of payouts divided by the 30 Sep price), GPIX paid out about 8.16% and VOO about 1.06%.

VOO is far bigger, at nearly $1 trillion in its ETF share class against about $6 billion for GPIX.


Main Difference between GPIX vs VOO

  • GPIX sells call options on part of the portfolio, which gives up some upside in strong months in exchange for monthly income
  • VOO holds the index as it is, so all of the gains stay in the share price, plus a small dividend
  • Goldman Sachs estimates the return of capital component of GPIX’s current distributions at 90.7% (as of 30 Sep 2026)
  • Goldman Sachs reports 12-month volatility of 11.08% for GPIX, against 12.75% for the S&P 500

For us in Singapore, dividend-type income from US-listed ETFs is generally subject to 30% US withholding tax, and both funds also count as US assets for US estate tax (IRS). With VOO the withholding bites on a small dividend; with GPIX it can bite on a large monthly payout, depending on how your broker treats the return of capital part. Please check with your broker.


Fund Composite GPIX vs VOO

Top 10 Holdings

Goldman Sachs S&P 500 Premium Income ETF (GPIX)Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO)
NVIDIA Corp (NVDA) / 8.21%NVIDIA Corp (NVDA) / 8.08%
Apple Inc. (AAPL) / 7.42%Apple Inc. (AAPL) / 7.03%
Microsoft Corp (MSFT) / 5.98%Microsoft Corp (MSFT) / 5.70%
Communication Services Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLC) / 3.77%Amazon.com (AMZN) / 3.84%
Amazon.com (AMZN) / 3.70%Alphabet Inc. (GOOGL) / 3.01%
Alphabet Inc. (GOOGL) / 3.36%Broadcom Inc. (AVGO) / 2.65%
Broadcom Inc. (AVGO) / 2.42%Alphabet Inc. (GOOG) / 2.40%
Micron Technology (MU) / 1.68%Meta Platforms (META) / 1.90%
Meta Platforms (META) / 1.63%Micron Technology (MU) / 1.63%
Tesla Inc. (TSLA) / 1.48%Tesla Inc. (TSLA) / 1.57%
39.65% of total asset37.81% of total asset
Sources: stockanalysis GPIX, 12 Oct 2026; stockanalysis VOO, 31 Aug 2026

From the above table, we can see that 9 of the top 10 counters are the same, with similar weights. GPIX’s list includes a communication services sector ETF (XLC) in place of VOO’s second Alphabet share class.

Sectors

SectorGPIXVOO
Electronic Technology29.87%28.97%
Technology Services17.08%18.56%
Finance12.50%13.44%
Health Technology7.45%7.54%
Retail Trade6.82%7.18%
Producer Manufacturing4.41%4.34%
Energy Minerals3.01%2.84%
Consumer Non-Durables2.83%2.91%
Utilities2.06%2.08%
Sources: etfdb GPIX, etfdb VOO, 13 Oct 2026

The sector mix is practically the same. When you buy GPIX, you are basically buying the S&P 500 with an options overlay.


Yield and Payouts

QuarterGPIX ($, 3 monthly payouts)VOO ($, ex-date)
Oct – Dec 20251.1191.771 (22 Dec 2025)
Jan – Mar 20261.1231.872 (27 Mar 2026)
Apr – Jun 20261.1331.962 (26 Jun 2026)
Jul – Sep 20261.1831.823 (28 Sep 2026)
12-month total4.5587.428
÷ 30 Sep 2026 closing price8.16% ($55.83)1.06% ($700.86)
Source: Yahoo Finance GPIX dividends, Yahoo Finance VOO dividends, 30 Sep 2026

VOO’s dollar payouts look bigger only because its share price is more than 12 times GPIX’s. As a percentage, GPIX pays out roughly eight times as much.


GPIX vs VOO – Performance

Now that we know the main differences between these ETFs, let’s see if these lead to a performance difference. GPIX is the younger fund, so I compared both from 27 Oct 2023, the first GPIX close in the Yahoo Finance data.

Since 27 Oct 2023

27 Oct 2023 – 30 Sep 2026GPIXVOO
Closing price on 27 Oct 2023$39.03$377.32
Closing price on 30 Sep 2026$55.83$700.86
Price return+43.06%+85.75%
Total return, distributions reinvested+82.10%+92.95%
Source: Yahoo Finance GPIX, Yahoo Finance VOO, 30 Sep 2026

This table shows the trade-off clearly. VOO’s share price rose about twice as much, and even with every GPIX payout reinvested, GPIX trailed VOO by about 10.9 percentage points over this period.

Calendar-Year Total Returns

PeriodGPIXVOO
2023 (partial: 27 Oct – 29 Dec)14.13%16.24%
202421.77%24.98%
202516.25%17.82%
2026 YTD to 30 Sep12.71%12.73%
1 year to 30 Sep 202616.38% (market price, published)15.77%
Sources: Goldman Sachs monthly update, 30 Sep 2026; Yahoo Finance GPIX, Yahoo Finance VOO, 30 Sep 2026

VOO was ahead in the strong years of 2023, 2024 and 2025. Over the past 12 months, though, GPIX has kept pace and slightly beaten VOO, with lower volatility.


What $10,000 Paid You

GPIXVOO
Closing price, 30 Sep 2025$52.23$612.38
Shares bought with $10,000191.4616.33
Payouts, Oct 2025 – Sep 2026124
Income before tax$873$121
Income after 30% withholding$611$85
Source: Yahoo Finance GPIX, Yahoo Finance VOO price and dividend history, 30 Sep 2026

If you had put $10,000 into each fund at the close on 30 Sep 2025, GPIX would have paid you about $873 and VOO about $121 over the next 12 months. After the 30% US withholding tax that generally applies to us in Singapore, that drops to about $611 and $85. Both funds are also US assets for US estate tax. Price changes are not included.


In Bad Times: Drawdowns and Payouts

GPIXVOO
Max drawdown, total return-17.5%-18.7%
Peak to trough19 Feb 2025 – 8 Apr 202519 Feb 2025 – 8 Apr 2025
Payout before the drop$0.350 (Nov 2024 – Jan 2025, monthly avg)$1.739 (Dec 2024, quarterly)
Payout during the drop$0.343 (Feb – Apr 2025, monthly avg)$1.812 (Mar 2025, quarterly)
Change in payout-2.1%+4.2%
Source: Yahoo Finance GPIX, Yahoo Finance VOO price and dividend history, 30 Sep 2026

Over the common period from 30 Jan 2024 to 30 Sep 2026, the worst fall for both funds came in the early-2025 sell-off. GPIX fell 17.5% and VOO 18.7% from peak to trough, with payouts reinvested, so VOO fell further. GPIX’s payout changed by -2.1% and VOO’s by +4.2% during the drop, compared with the months before it.


Conclusion – Is GPIX’s Extra Income Worth It?

Based on the history we have, VOO has delivered the higher total return at a much lower fee (0.03% vs 0.29% net), while GPIX pays a much higher income with a bit less volatility.

If you want maximum long-term growth, then VOO might be the better choice. If you want regular monthly income from the S&P 500 and are happy to give up some upside, then GPIX might be the one to go with.

For Singapore-based investors, the 30% US withholding tax hits VOO’s small dividend far less than GPIX’s large monthly payout, and both funds count as US assets for US estate tax.

Ireland-domiciled alternative? CSPX tracks the same S&P 500 Index as VOO; nothing is truly close for GPIX.

AlternativeTypeISINTERPayoutClosest toKey difference
iShares Core S&P 500 UCITS ETF USD (Acc) (CSPX)UCITS fundIE00B5BMR0870.07%None (accumulating)VOOPlain S&P 500, no options
JPMorgan US Equity Premium Income Active UCITS ETF USD (dist)UCITS fundIE000U5MJOZ60.35%MonthlyGPIXActive, lower-volatility US stocks plus calls
IncomeShares S&P 500 Options ETPETPXS28751062420.45%MonthlyGPIXA note, not a fund; holds SPY, sells puts
iShares U.S. Equity High Income Active UCITS ETF USD (Dist) (INCU)UCITS fundIE000WHL2ZK10.35%Monthly (per iShares)GPIXActive US large caps plus index calls and futures
iShares World Equity High Income Active UCITS ETF USD (Dist) (WINC)UCITS fundIE000KJPDY610.35%Monthly (per iShares)GPIX (global option)Global developed stocks, not US-only, plus index calls and futures
All Ireland-domiciled. Sources (justETF; IncomeShares for its ETPs): CSPX, JPM US, IncomeShares S&P 500, INCU (iShares), INCU (justETF), WINC (iShares), WINC (justETF), accessed 15 Oct 2026.

No Goldman Sachs UCITS version was found. GPIX holds the S&P 500 near index weights, while the JPMorgan fund picks defensive stocks. The IncomeShares ETPs are notes issued by Leverage Shares PLC, so holders carry issuer, collateral and counterparty risk.


Related

  • SPYI vs GPIX
  • GPIX vs JEPI
  • GPIX vs GPIQ
  • GPIX vs SCHD
  • GPIX vs DIVO

As always, remember that Past Performance is No Guarantee of Future Results. And none of the content that I write on this site should be taken as financial advice.

Suz avatar

Suz

I left my tech job at 45 and now build income from dividends, covered call ETFs and selling options. This is where I share what I’m learning.

Leave a Reply

● About Me
Suz avatar

I’m Suz, and this is my journey of learning to live off my investment portfolio without a regular paycheck.

Read my story →