A monthly payout of 15% sounds attractive. But what if your investment is barely growing while the Nasdaq keeps climbing?
That’s the question I’ve been asking myself as I work towards generating USD 10,000 a month in investment income.
Since leaving my full-time job, monthly cash flow has become more important to me. Covered call ETFs are appealing because they can generate regular distributions without requiring me to sell shares every month.
But I don’t want to focus so much on income that I end up sacrificing long-term portfolio growth.
So I decided to compare four Nasdaq-focused income ETFs: QQQI, TDAQ, GPIQ and JEPQ, using QQQ as the benchmark.
I wanted to find out three things: how much income each fund pays, how much Nasdaq growth it captures, and whether the higher payouts actually translate into better overall returns.
The results were interesting. The fund paying the most income also delivered the highest total return over the period I examined. But that doesn’t mean it’s necessarily the best choice.
QQQI vs TDAQ vs GPIQ vs JEPQ: What’s the Difference?
All four ETFs provide exposure to Nasdaq-focused stocks while using options to generate income.
In simple terms, selling call options allows a fund to collect premiums in exchange for giving up some potential gains if the market rises strongly.
The difference is how each fund implements that strategy.
| ETF | Options strategy | Expense ratio |
|---|---|---|
| QQQI | Actively manages Nasdaq-100 index call options | 0.68% |
| TDAQ | Sells daily call options that expire the same day | 0.68% |
| GPIQ | Sells calls on part of its portfolio | 0.29%* |
| JEPQ | Uses equity-linked notes to generate options income | 0.35% |
GPIQ generally leaves a larger portion of its portfolio without calls written against it. That gives it more opportunity to participate in a rising market.
TDAQ takes a different approach. Its options expire on the same trading day, allowing it to reset its strategy daily.
JEPQ combines an actively managed stock portfolio with equity-linked notes, or ELNs. These are financial instruments whose returns depend on underlying assets and options strategies. They also introduce counterparty risk.
QQQI actively manages its index options, sometimes buying calls as well as selling them.
The strategies may sound similar, but their performance shows how differently they can behave. For more comparisons, see my covered call ETF comparison tool and my QQQI vs JEPQ comparison.
Which ETF Pays the Most Monthly Income?
For someone trying to replace a regular paycheck, the amount of cash received matters.
Here is how the four funds compared using the distribution figures from my original analysis.
| ETF | Annualised latest payout rate | Cash paid per USD 10,000 over 12 months |
|---|---|---|
| TDAQ | 18.52% | USD 1,715 |
| QQQI | 14.88% | USD 1,413 |
| JEPQ | 11.53% | USD 1,203 |
| GPIQ | 10.66% | USD 1,101 |
TDAQ came out on top, paying USD 1,715 for every USD 10,000 invested over the preceding 12 months.
That’s substantially more cash than GPIQ.
But there’s an important distinction between distribution yield and investment return.
A fund paying 15% in distributions doesn’t necessarily mean you’ve earned 15%.
Some of that cash may come alongside a decline in the value of your shares. Distributions can also include amounts classified as return of capital.
How Much Nasdaq Growth Did Each ETF Capture?
This was the comparison I was most interested in.
If I’m giving up potential growth in exchange for monthly income, I want to know how much growth I’m sacrificing.
To measure that, I looked at upside capture and downside capture.
Upside capture measures how a fund performed relative to QQQ during months when QQQ rose. Downside capture measures how it performed during months when QQQ fell.
For example, 80% upside capture means the fund historically gained about 80% as much as QQQ in rising months, using the calculation method in this analysis. It doesn’t mean the fund will capture exactly 80% of every future rally.
Here are the results.
| ETF | Upside capture | Downside capture |
|---|---|---|
| TDAQ | 94% | 92% |
| GPIQ | 83% | 73% |
| QQQI | 73% | 76% |
| JEPQ | 64% | 52% |
| QQQ | 100% | 100% |
TDAQ captured the most upside at 94%. That sounds attractive, but it also experienced 92% of QQQ’s downside.
In other words, TDAQ behaved much more like QQQ than the other income funds.
JEPQ was at the opposite end. It captured only 64% of QQQ’s upside, but also experienced just 52% of its downside.
GPIQ sat somewhere in between, capturing 83% of the upside and 73% of the downside.
QQQI was less impressive during this particular period. It captured 73% of the upside while experiencing 76% of the downside.
That doesn’t make QQQI a bad fund. It simply means its strategy didn’t offer as attractive an upside-versus-downside balance over these months.
One limitation is that these percentages cover a relatively short period. They shouldn’t be treated as reliable predictions of how the funds will behave in a future bear market.
Which ETF Actually Made Investors More Money?
This is where the comparison becomes more meaningful.
Rather than looking only at the cash distributed, I compared total returns from 4 September 2025 to 13 November 2026.
Total return includes both changes in share value and distributions, assuming those distributions are reinvested.
| ETF | Share price change | Total return |
|---|---|---|
| TDAQ | −0.69% | +19.61% |
| QQQ | +18.19% | +18.88% |
| GPIQ | +4.68% | +18.35% |
| JEPQ | +0.95% | +15.42% |
| QQQI | −3.75% | +13.45% |
TDAQ delivered the highest total return, slightly ahead of QQQ.
That surprised me because I usually expect covered call strategies to underperform during a rising market.
GPIQ also performed well, coming relatively close to QQQ.
JEPQ and QQQI lagged further behind.
But look at the share price changes.
QQQ gained 18.19% in price alone. Meanwhile, TDAQ’s price fell slightly and QQQI’s fell 3.75%.
Their distributions contributed heavily to their total returns.
This is exactly why comparing only dividend or distribution yields can be misleading.
What If You Took the Income Instead of Reinvesting It?
The total return figures assume distributions are reinvested.
But if you’re using these ETFs to pay your monthly expenses, you probably aren’t reinvesting every dollar.
So I also looked at what would have happened if you invested USD 10,000 in each fund on 4 September 2025 and collected all the distributions as cash.
| ETF | Shares remaining | Cash collected | Combined value |
|---|---|---|---|
| QQQI | $9,625 | $1,679 | $11,304 |
| TDAQ | $9,931 | $1,955 | $11,886 |
| GPIQ | $10,468 | $1,322 | $11,790 |
| JEPQ | $10,095 | $1,414 | $11,509 |
| QQQ | $11,819 | $66 | $11,885 |
QQQI would have paid you USD 1,679 in cash, but your remaining shares would have been worth only USD 9,625.
You would still have made money overall, assuming you kept the distributions. But your invested capital, measured by the market value of the shares, would have declined.
TDAQ paid almost USD 2,000 in cash while leaving the share value close to the original USD 10,000.
GPIQ paid less cash, but its remaining shares appreciated.
QQQ barely paid any income, yet the shares themselves grew substantially.
For someone who doesn’t need monthly income, QQQ’s growth may be perfectly acceptable. You could sell a small portion of your holdings whenever you need cash, although doing so reduces your share count and exposes you to the risk of selling during a downturn.
For someone relying on monthly distributions, the income ETFs offer a different way to generate cash flow.
Neither approach is automatically better. They simply serve different needs.
What Happened During the Recent Nasdaq Sell-Off?
High distributions are attractive when markets are doing well. But I also want to know what happens when prices fall.
Between 6 October and 13 November 2026, QQQ declined 10.50% on a total-return basis in the original analysis.
Here’s how the four income ETFs performed over the same period.
| ETF | Total return |
|---|---|
| JEPQ | −7.38% |
| QQQI | −8.70% |
| GPIQ | −8.81% |
| TDAQ | −10.12% |
| QQQ | −10.50% |
JEPQ held up the best during this particular decline.
TDAQ, despite paying the highest income, fell almost as much as QQQ.
This is a reminder that a covered call strategy isn’t the same as downside protection.
Options premiums can help offset losses, but the underlying stocks can still fall sharply. A high monthly payout doesn’t prevent your portfolio from losing value.
And while JEPQ performed better during this sell-off, there’s no guarantee it will do so in the next one.
What Singapore Investors Should Consider
As a Singapore-based investor, I also have to think about taxes.
All four ETFs in this comparison are US-listed. Distributions classified as US-source dividends are generally subject to 30% withholding tax for Singapore investors, although the treatment of return-of-capital distributions can differ. See IRS Publication 515.
The actual amount received therefore depends on how the fund’s distributions are classified and processed.
There’s also US estate tax exposure to consider. For non-US citizens who are not US-domiciled, US-situated assets can trigger estate tax filing requirements when their value exceeds USD 60,000 at death. That is a filing threshold, not a blanket tax-free allowance.
One alternative is to consider Ireland-domiciled UCITS ETFs.
Some Nasdaq-focused income funds available through this structure include:
| Fund | ISIN | Expense ratio |
|---|---|---|
| JPMorgan Nasdaq Equity Premium Income Active UCITS ETF | IE000U9J8HX9 | 0.35% |
| Global X Nasdaq 100 Covered Call UCITS ETF | IE00BM8R0J59 | 0.45% |
| HANetf Nasdaq 100 Daily Covered Call UCITS ETF | IE0008IQ0DI1 | 0.59% |
Ireland-domiciled funds generally avoid direct US estate tax exposure for the investor, although withholding taxes may still apply within the fund.
The UCITS versions aren’t necessarily identical to the US-listed funds. Their strategies, expenses and returns need to be compared separately.
For me, taxes matter because what ultimately counts is the money I get to keep.
Which Nasdaq Income ETF Would I Choose?
After comparing these four funds, I don’t think there’s a single winner for every investor.
TDAQ stands out for income and upside participation. It paid the most cash and delivered the highest total return during the period. But it also experienced almost as much downside as QQQ, and its track record is still short.
GPIQ offers an interesting balance. It captured a good portion of Nasdaq’s gains while providing some downside cushioning during the measured months. Its lower payout may be less appealing if monthly cash flow is the main objective.
JEPQ looks more defensive in this comparison. It gave up more upside but held up better when QQQ declined. That may appeal to investors who prioritise smoother returns over maximum growth, although it still carries substantial equity risk.
QQQI offers a high distribution rate, but its total return and upside-versus-downside capture were less competitive over this particular period.
Personally, I don’t want to build my income portfolio by simply chasing whichever ETF has the highest yield.
My challenge is finding a balance between generating enough cash to support life without a regular paycheck and allowing my investments to keep growing.
After all, USD 10,000 a month in distributions would mean much less to me if the portfolio producing it kept shrinking.
That’s why I still see a role for growth investments alongside income-producing ETFs.
The question I’m continuing to work through is how much growth I’m willing to give up for the convenience of monthly cash flow.
If you’re investing in covered call ETFs, do you focus more on the monthly distributions or on total returns? You can also read about my October 2026 options income.
Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and isn’t financial advice. Historical performance doesn’t guarantee future results. The figures are based on the original comparison and should be independently checked before publication or investment decisions.






Leave a Reply