Guide to Choosing Which S&P 500 ETF to Buy

—

Recently, my colleague asked me about how to get started in investing. And I just told her what everyone else recommends, just buy the S&P500 ETF or a world index ETF.

A couple weeks later, I asked her, so have you started your investment? And her reply was, there are so many S&P500 ETFs! I didn’t know which one to buy!

So here goes.

Updated 2 November 2026: I refreshed every fee, fund size and return from the fund providers’ own pages, and added the S&P 500 ETFs that have launched or been renamed since the last version. Each table says where the numbers came from and the date they are as of. They change often, so check the provider’s page before you act on them.

What actually differs between S&P 500 ETFs

They all follow the same index of 500 large US companies, so the holdings are basically the same. What differs is:

  • Fee (expense ratio or ongoing charge)
  • Domicile, meaning the country the fund is legally set up in, which decides how it is taxed
  • Accumulating or distributing, meaning whether dividends are reinvested or paid out
  • How it is built: physical (holds the shares) or synthetic (uses a swap)
  • Size, trading volume and trading hours

US Domiciled ETFs

These are the ETFs listed in the US, mostly on NYSE Arca. They are all distributing.

State Street’s own comparison says there are four unleveraged S&P 500 ETFs in the US: SPYM, SPY, IVV and VOO (Bloomberg data, 26 June 2026). SPYM is the one that has changed since my last update. It used to be called SPLG, and was renamed SPYM with the ticker change effective 31 October 2025 (SEC filing).

NYSE ArcaExpense ratioAssets30-day SEC yield
SPYM
(State Street)
0.02%$185.3B
(29 Oct 2026)
1.04%
SPY
(State Street)
0.0945%$813.6B
(29 Oct 2026)
0.96%
IVV
(BlackRock)
0.03%$870.0B
(30 Oct 2026)
0.95%
VOO
(Vanguard)
0.03%$1,032.3B ETF share class; $1,732.0B whole fund
(30 Sep 2026)
1.00%
Sources: SPYM, SPY, IVV, VOO and VOO factsheet. Expense ratios as published on each page. Assets as of the dates shown. 30-day SEC yield as of 30 Sep 2026. Checked 2 Nov 2026.

Non-U.S. residents are subject to U.S. estate tax on US assets they own when they die. The IRS says a non-resident who is not a US citizen has to file an estate tax return if their US-situated assets are above USD$60,000 (IRS FAQ). StashAway puts the rate at 18% to 40%, depending on the value above the threshold (StashAway, 12 Oct 2026).

Dividend Withholding Tax is another consideration for us. The IRS standard rate for US dividends paid to non-resident aliens is 30% unless a tax treaty gives a lower rate (IRS). The IRS treaty list has Ireland on it but not Singapore (IRS treaty table), so as Singapore residents we are usually taxed at 30% on dividends from US-listed ETFs.

In simple terms, for us Singaporeans, these two tax points are the reason many long-term buy-and-hold investors look at Ireland-domiciled ETFs instead of US-domiciled ones (see the next section).

Short-term traders and options traders often use the US-listed ETFs, because trading happens during US hours and the market is very liquid.

Imagine you hold an ETF listed on the LSE (London exchange) and a surprise US interest rate announcement comes out during US hours. Your ETF can’t be sold at that moment because the London market is closed. A US-listed ETF can be.

US-listed ETFs also have listed options, so you can sell covered call options on your holdings. This isn’t something you can do with ETFs listed on the LSE.

Why does SPY cost more than IVV, VOO or SPYM?

SPY’s expense ratio (0.0945%) is higher than IVV’s and VOO’s (0.03%) and SPYM’s (0.02%). I wrote about the difference between IVV and VOO separately.

SPY is often used for short-term trading and options because of its liquidity.

Ireland Domiciled ETFs

Ireland Domiciled ETFs (UCITS ETFs) can be found listed on the London Stock Exchange (LSE) and on other European exchanges such as Xetra. You can look under the fund factsheet of the ETF to see its domicile. Not every UCITS S&P 500 ETF is Irish: the Xtrackers swap fund below is domiciled in Luxembourg.

There are a lot more S&P 500 UCITS ETFs now than in my last update. Below are the main ones I could confirm from the fund providers’ own factsheets. This list is not exhaustive.

Fund (ticker)Acc / DistFeeAssets
iShares Core S&P 500 UCITS ETF
CSPX
Acc0.07%$153.8B share class; $156.9B fund
(30 Oct 2026)
iShares Core S&P 500 UCITS ETF
IUSA
Dist (quarterly)0.07%$22.6B share class
(30 Oct 2026)
Vanguard S&P 500 UCITS ETF
VUAA
Acc0.07%$36.3B share class; $89.0B fund
(30 Sep 2026)
Vanguard S&P 500 UCITS ETF
VUSD (VUSA on some lines)
Dist0.07%$52.6B share class; $89.0B fund
(30 Sep 2026)
State Street SPDR S&P 500 UCITS ETF
SPYL
Acc0.03%$19.2B share class; $43.8B fund
(30 Sep 2026)
State Street SPDR S&P 500 UCITS ETF
SPY5
Dist (quarterly)0.03%$21.1B share class; $43.8B fund
(30 Sep 2026)
Invesco S&P 500 UCITS ETF
SPXS (Acc) / SPXD (Dist)
Acc / Dist0.05% + 0.07% swap fee = 0.12%$59.0B whole fund
(30 Sep 2026)
UBS Core S&P 500 UCITS ETF
S5UU (LSE, USD) new 2025
Acc0.03%$2.4B share class; $5.0B fund
(30 Sep 2026)
Xtrackers S&P 500 UCITS ETF 4D
X5SP new 2025
Dist0.03%$4.2B fund
(30 Sep 2026)
Amundi Core S&P 500 UCITS ETF Acc
CSP6 (Xetra, USD) new 2025
Acc0.03%$25.6M
(30 Sep 2026)
HSBC S&P 500 UCITS ETF
HSPX
Dist (semi-annual)0.09%$10.5B fund
(30 Sep 2026)
Xtrackers S&P 500 Swap UCITS ETF 1C
XSPX (LSE USD line: XSPU)
Acc0.15%$9.1B fund
(30 Sep 2026)
Fees are the ongoing charge or total expense ratio on each fund’s factsheet (Xtrackers shows an all-in fee). Sources: iShares CSPX and iShares IUSA (30 Oct 2026); Vanguard; SPDR SPYL and SPDR SPY5; Invesco factsheet; UBS and UBS factsheet; Xtrackers 4D; Amundi factsheet; HSBC factsheet; Xtrackers XSPX. Factsheets dated 30 Sep 2026 unless shown. Checked 2 Nov 2026.

A few things in the table are new or changed since last time:

  • New funds from other providers. UBS Core S&P 500 launched on 5 August 2025. Xtrackers S&P 500 UCITS ETF 4D launched on 20 August 2025, and the same fund also has an accumulating class, the 4C. Amundi Core S&P 500 Acc launched on 10 April 2025. Its assets are still small, at $25.6M.
  • Amundi Core S&P 500 Dist (ticker CSPS on Xetra) launched in September 2026 with a 0.03% TER and annual distributions. It had no meaningful assets yet when I checked, so it is not in the table.
  • State Street SPYL was renamed in February 2026. It now has “USD Unhedged (Acc)” in the name, but it is the same accumulating fund.
  • Invesco’s cost is more than the 0.05% headline. Invesco’s factsheet says the total cost is the ongoing charge plus the swap fee, so 0.05% + 0.07% = 0.12%. The fund is synthetic, meaning it holds a swap rather than the shares themselves. It also did a 100-for-1 share split on 15 December 2025, so the price per unit is much lower than it was.
FundDomicileHow it is builtShare class launched
CSPXIrelandPhysical19 May 2010
IUSAIrelandPhysical15 Mar 2002
VUAAIrelandPhysical14 May 2019
VUSDIrelandPhysical22 May 2012
SPYLIrelandReplicated (holds the shares)31 Oct 2023
SPY5IrelandReplicated (holds the shares)19 Mar 2012
SPXS / SPXDIrelandSynthetic (swap)20 May 2010 (fund)
S5UU (UBS)IrelandPhysical5 Aug 2025
X5SP (Xtrackers 4D)IrelandPhysical20 Aug 2025
CSP6 (Amundi Acc)IrelandPhysical10 Apr 2025
HSPXIrelandPhysical14 May 2010 (fund)
XSPXLuxembourgSynthetic (swap)26 Mar 2010

Distributing or Accumulating

“Distributing” means you’ll receive dividends directly from the ETF.

“Accumulating” means the fund reinvests those dividends to buy more units, increasing your holdings instead of paying out cash.

Why do people look at Ireland-domiciled ETFs?

They are usually mentioned for two reasons:

  • Shares in Irish-domiciled funds are generally not treated as US assets, so the US estate tax point above is usually described as not applying (StashAway)
  • A reduced 15% Dividend Withholding Tax, because the US-Ireland tax treaty applies to the dividends the fund receives (State Street)

Tax treatment depends on your own situation, and the 15% is withheld inside the fund, so you don’t see it as a separate deduction. Check with a tax adviser if you aren’t sure. The Luxembourg-domiciled Xtrackers swap fund is not an Irish fund, so the Ireland points above do not automatically apply to it.

What to compare between Ireland-domiciled ETFs

  • Fee: the funds in the table run from 0.03% to 0.15%. On a made-up USD 10,000, 0.03% is USD 3 a year and 0.07% is USD 7. My post on how the expense ratio affects returns shows how this adds up over time.
  • Size and liquidity: CSPX is the largest share class in the table, and the newest funds are much smaller. I compared how liquid CSPX is against IWDA and VWRA in another post. Check the bid-ask spread and volume on your own broker for the fund you are looking at.
  • Accumulating or distributing: pick the class that matches whether you want the dividends paid out or reinvested.
  • Physical or synthetic: physical funds hold the shares. Synthetic funds (Invesco, Xtrackers swap) use a swap, which adds counterparty risk.

Past returns

Past returns of the same index look almost the same across funds. The small gaps come mostly from fees and from how much US dividend tax each fund bears. These are NAV (fund price) returns in USD, annualised for 3 and 5 years, to 30 September 2026.

Fund1 year3 years p.a.5 years p.a.
VOO15.70%22.85%13.75%
IVV15.71%22.85%13.76%
SPY15.60%22.73%13.65%
SPYM15.70%22.84%13.76%
CSPX15.47%22.57%13.48%
VUAA / VUSD15.46%22.57%13.48%
SPY515.48%22.58%13.48%
SPYL15.49%––
SPXS (Invesco)15.60%22.8%13.7%
HSPX15.44%22.55%13.46%
UBS Core (S5UU)15.50%––
Amundi Core Acc (CSP6)15.45%––
Sources: the fund factsheets and pages linked above (issuer figures to 30 Sep 2026). Past performance is not a guide to future returns.

Summary

Decide if you are trading or investing for long term.

People who trade short term or trade options usually use US-listed ETFs, because of US trading hours, liquidity and listed options.

For long term investing, the choice mostly comes down to tax and personal preference:

  • If you are a US resident, the US estate tax and the 30% non-resident withholding tax above do not apply in the same way to you, so the four US-listed funds mostly differ by fee: SPYM is lowest at 0.02%, then IVV and VOO at 0.03%, then SPY at 0.0945%.
  • If you are a non-US resident, such as most of us in Singapore, the Ireland-domiciled funds are the ones usually compared because of the estate tax and 15% withholding points. Among those, the differences are fee (0.03% to 0.15%), size, accumulating or distributing, and physical or synthetic.
  • If you want the dividends paid out, the distributing classes are IUSA, VUSD, SPY5, SPXD, X5SP, HSPX and the new Amundi Dist.

I personally hold CSPX because it has the largest AUM.

As always, none of what is mentioned here is financial advice. Always do your own research.

Suz avatar

Suz

I left my tech job at 45 and now build income from dividends, covered call ETFs and selling options. This is where I share what I’m learning.

● About Me
Suz avatar

I’m Suz, and this is my journey of learning to live off my investment portfolio without a regular paycheck.

Read my story →